Other Welfare Issues
Slaughter of Animals for Food
Content Warning:
This article contains graphic images or descriptions related to the slaughter of farmed animals.
Reader discretion is advised.
Farmed land animals are usually slaughtered at a different place to the farm where they were raised, in a facility called a slaughterhouse, also known as an abattoir.
The slaughter process, by its very nature, can cause the animal to suffer not only intense physical pain, but also physiological and psychological stress, not to mention negative emotions such as fear.
To try to reduce the physical suffering of animals during slaughter, it is common practice in many countries that animals should be stunned before slaughter, so that they are unconscious when they are killed.
However, stunning is not required in every country. Even in countries where it is the norm, there may be exceptions on religious grounds. For example, the Jewish method of slaughter called shechita does not allow any pre-slaughter stunning at all. The acceptability of stunning methods for preparing Halal-slaughtered meat has been extensively debated. Over the last few decades, reversible stunning methods have become more acceptable for Halal slaughtering due to an increasing majority of Muslim countries issuing Fatwas (religious rulings) that approve of stunning methods for the Halal slaughtering of food animals.
Several European countries, including Denmark, Belgium, Norway, Iceland, Slovenia, Sweden have banned all slaughter of farmed animals without pre-stunning. There is no exception to this rule on religious grounds. This is also the case in New Zealand.
In the case of Southeast Asia, pre-slaughter stunning is generally mentioned and recommended in the laws relating to animal welfare for most (though not all) countries. However, there are many documented cases in Southeast Asian countries of animals not being adequately stunned before the slaughter process, and this means that the animals will have suffered greatly by being conscious while their arteries and jugular veins were severed with a knife.
Slaughterhouses typically handle many animals per day, and slaughterhouse workers may be paid for how many animals they slaughter. Consequently, stunning may be rushed or overlooked to save time, resulting in animals being fully conscious when they are killed. Working at speed may also result in the killing process being rushed, meaning that it may not be carried out in the most effective way and animals may take longer to die (and therefore suffer for a longer time) than if the slaughter process was completed properly.
It is important to note that even if animals are stunned effectively prior to slaughter and rendered unconscious, it is still highly probable that they suffered extreme fear and stress prior to slaughter.
Another point to note is that in countries where chickens and ducks are displayed live at wet markets and slaughtered on the spot after they have been purchased, there is often little or no regulation in the slaughter process. The animals may not be stunned, equipment may be basic, and unskilled individuals may perform the task. Animals often witness fellow animals being slaughtered, which for these sentient beings, who appear to empathise with each other, is probably highly stressful and also is likely to cause feelings of fear and panic.
A chicken bleeds to death after having her throat slit at a small-scale slaughterhouse in Hanoi, Vietnam. She was not stunned prior to slaughter despite welfare laws in the country stating that this is mandatory. Hanoi, Vietnam.
Credit: Amy Jones / Moving Animals / We Animals Media.
Mammals
For mammals, the usual method of killing is to suspend the animal upside down by his or her back leg/s, then the major veins and arteries in the body (carotid arteries and jugular veins, or the blood vessels from which they arise) are severed with a knife. This is done by using a sharp knife to cut open the animal's body (neck or chest), then severing these veins and arteries - a process called “sticking” by the industry- and the animal then bleeds to death.
Steers (young neutered male cattle) hung by their back legs and bleeding out at a slaughterhouse.
Credit: Jo-Anne McArthur / Eyes On Animals / We Animals Media.
Animals may be stunned prior to slaughter using a variety of methods. These procedures must be carried out carefully to ensure they are effective in rendering the animal unconscious. If stunning is not done properly, there is a high chance that the animal will be conscious during the sticking process.
For cattle, stunning is achieved by using a penetrative captive bolt- a gun is used to fire a metal bolt into the brain, with the intention of causing the cow to lose consciousness. This method can also be used on sheep and pigs. If this is not done properly, the animal may not be rendered fully unconscious, and may suffer considerable pain from the bolt.
A bull being stunned before slaughter with a captive bolt gun.
Credit: Jo-Anne McArthur / Eyes On Animals / We Animals Media.
Pigs and sheep are more commonly stunned by having an electric shock applied to their brains using tongs placed on either side of the head. Stunning with electricity is known as electronarcosis. If done properly this causes a temporary loss of consciousness. If it is not done properly, the animal may be conscious during the slaughter process.
A small pig is clasped around the head and neck and electrocuted while the rest of the group huddles in the corner awaiting their turn at a slaughterhouse.
Credit: Gabriela Penela / We Animals Media.
Another method used for pigs is gassing, in which pigs are subjected to high levels of carbon dioxide inside a stunning chamber, which causes them to lose consciousness after about 90 seconds. This method has generated controversy, with veterinarians and others raising concerns that this method causes extreme physical pain to the animals, as the carbon dioxide gas forms an acid on their eyes, nostrils, mouth and lungs. Pigs have been documented exhibiting signs of extreme distress in gassing changers before finally losing consciousness.
Birds
Chickens, ducks and geese are slaughtered by having their throats cut whilst hanging upside down, shackled by their legs on a conveyor belt-type system . Due to the large numbers of birds being killed per day in a typical slaughterhouse setting, the throat cutting is usually carried out by a mechanical neck cutter, which cuts the major arteries and veins in the neck. The birds then bleed to death. The mechanisation of this process means that it is not always carried out effectively, and birds may be cut in the wrong place and take a long time to bleed to bleed out.
After their throats have been cut, the birds are thrown into vats of scalding water to facilitate feather removal. If stunning was ineffective and the chicken is still alive at this point, the birds may be scalded alive.
In some countries, such as the UK most birds are now killed (not just stunned) by the gassing method, using a variety of gases and gassing chambers. This is thought by some to be more humane than traditional methods of cutting the throat, although there are still welfare concerns.
Stunning of birds
Chickens, ducks and geese are often stunned by electrocution. The birds are shackled by the legs and hung upside down on a moving conveyor belt. Their heads are dragged through a water bath with an electrical current running through it, and when the bird's head makes contact with the water, an electrical circuit between the water bath and shackle is completed, which stuns the bird. This method of stunning is limited in its efficiency, as birds can struggle and flap their wings and lift their heads out of the water. The process is also likely to cause stress and panic in the birds. An alternative stunning method is controlled atmosphere stunning, which involves exposing birds to carbon dioxide or an inert gas combination (such as argon or nitrogen) prior to shackling.
Broiler chickens arrive at a slaughterhouse in Thailand in plastic containers from which workers remove them and shackle them to a conveyor belt. They are first dunked in a bath of water and electricity to stun them before their throats are slit by a worker. Not all the chickens are stunned and many reach the killing station still conscious and struggling.
Credit: Andrew Skowron / We Animals Media.
Fish
Farmed fish are slaughtered using a variety of methods. The most humane are electrical stunning or a strike to the head. However, other methods that involve immense suffering are commonly used, including cutting the gills without stunning or gassing with carbon dioxide. Some fish are simply left to suffocate in air or on ice, or may be processed while still alive.
Live tilapia slowly suffocate on a table at an Indonesian fish slaughterhouse. A worker uses a wooden stick to strike and kill fish as part of the slaughtering process.
Credit: Lilly Agustina / Act For Farmed Animals / We Animals Media.
Shrimp are usually left without food for at least 24 hours before being killed to make their bodies more appealing to consumers. They have an intestinal tract, also known as the ‘back vein’, which is filled with blackened food that they are digesting. Through starvation, these visible excreta are passed out of the body.
When prawns and shrimp reach the desired weight, they may be killed by asphyxiation or by being immersed in ‘chill-kill tanks’, full of ice and water.